Quote:Last really good Dr were david and matt!
Have to disagree with this.
Eccleston was excellent. The only reason his Doctor isn't more highly regarded is he only did one series. And the FIRST series at that, when the production team was still finding it's feet in terms of style and storytelling.
Capaldi had the greatest potential of all the modern Doctors. An older actor with the experience and the gravitas the part needs. His problem was that the showrunner was losing his way at that time, and as a consequence Capaldi never got any great material to work with.
But they were both just as good as Tennant and Smith in their own ways.
The first one that you mentioned seemed to be angry all time, while other one seemed to be like in "grumpy Grandpa" mode!