|Community >> View Post|
Subj: It depends on what you mean.
Posted: Sat Jan 08, 2022 at 11:04:47 pm EST (Viewed 254 times)
Reply Subj: Re: Yes basically that's it, and we should be realistic.
Posted: Sat Jan 08, 2022 at 09:07:16 pm EST (Viewed 264 times)
In communism, those bureaucrats in
charge of distributing the wealth favor their families and golfing
buddies. They then require ever more amounts of policing power to
enforce this disparity, resulting in a constant seesaw where the
goods given to the people get ever smaller, requiring ever more
policing power to prevent a rebellion from resulting, resulting in
even less money getting distributed to the people, requiring even
more money be given to the policing needed to prevent rebellion,
until the country is just a feudal system in which the Feudal Lords
are called bureaucrats.
LGDB: well communism by definition is a classless society, so if only government bureaucrats control the means of production that's a sharp class difference and thus not communism. But besides the semantics if the idea is regardless of the situation things will always get worse or decay or there's always entropy, I'm not really sure that that's more than a quietism, politics will only get worse regardless of what we try. I'm not sure how useful the political pessimism really is.
And more importantly there's a pretty strong differentiation right up top: with communism, people are trying to achieve a classless society where no one class privately owns the levers of power. And they might fail even most of the time, but capitalism just accepts as a positive good the unequal, private control of society. So based on my values I don't see them as equivalent systems.
And I think tribalism is bad sure, but that's also a bit vague. What is the answer? Just surrendering to tribalism? Accept that no politics can overcome tribalism? That's not a problem for communism, it's a problem for any political project.
Also, could you respond to the idea that the Iron Law of Oligarchy was coined by a literal fascist? I don't think that's something we wanna gloss over.
--- the late great Donald Blake
Posted with Google Chrome 96.0.4664.104 on Linux
|Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software|